Benson Boone’s ‘American Heart’ Review: A Bold Leap into Mainstream Pop-Rock

Explore Benson Boone’s ‘American Heart,’ a pop-rock album blending catchy hooks with theatrical flair, aiming for the heart of mainstream audiences.

The Curious Case of Benson Boone’s Rise

You might wonder why Benson Boone has attracted such mixed reactions online. Think of him as the budget-friendly version of Harry Styles—a bargain that somehow still draws attention. The 22-year-old burst into the spotlight at the Grammys with an unforgettable moment: a tuxedo rip, a front flip off the piano, and, yes, a cheeky crotch grab.

Benson Boone making a bold statement at the Grammys.

Before that spectacle, Boone quietly built his profile on TikTok, appeared briefly on American Idol, and dropped a debut album in 2024 called Fireworks & Rollerblades. That album featured the hit “Beautiful Things,” a song that perfectly encapsulates his style: guitar-driven, hook-heavy, and backed by powerful vocals that emphasize emotion more than depth.

His second album, American Heart, is a quick 10-track collection created in just 17 days alongside collaborator Jack LaFrantz. It feels rushed, seemingly aimed at capitalizing on the momentum from his Grammy moment.

What’s Behind ‘American Heart’?

Despite its patriotic title and cover showing Boone wrapped in an American flag—looking every bit the hardworking guy next door—American Heart is, surprisingly, a love letter to his younger, idealistic self. Boone shared this insight during an appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon.

Far from a wild rockstar stereotype, Boone is refreshingly wholesome: he avoids alcohol and drugs (though he jokingly admits to a candy addiction) and even wrote a heartfelt song about his mom. This album tells the story of a young man’s coming-of-age, chasing dreams that might seem a bit over-the-top, like wearing a jumpsuit and causing a stir at the Grammys.

The Sound of ‘American Heart’

The album kicks off with “Sorry I’m Here For Someone Else,” a catchy, pulsating pop-rock tune that sounds like it could easily be a solo B-side from Brandon Flowers. Half the tracks stick to this vibe, delivering punchy, shouty pop-rock anthems. But then there’s “Magical Mystical,” a track that feels like an overenthusiastic musical theater kid who won’t give up — a bit much for some listeners.

The rest of the album is dominated by mushy ballads that, while aiming for emotional depth, often come off as overly sentimental and somewhat bland.

“Benson Boone is Springsteen with a Huel subscription, Freddie Mercury if he preferred Tangfastics to coke.”
— Music Critic’s Take

Boone’s style feels like a polished, smartphone-friendly update of pop-rock that’s been done better and edgier before. While there’s definitely a place for this kind of music, it often feels like Boone is just filling a spot while Harry Styles is busy with his next venture.

Bright moments do shine through, such as the driving drum beat on “I Wanna Be The One You Call.” But then you hit tracks like the overly dramatic “Momma Song,” which risks making listeners want to disconnect entirely.

Wrapping It Up: The Landing

It’s tempting to say Boone’s daring Grammy stunt was a flop, but that’s not quite right. He landed exactly where he aimed: into a realm of bombastic, overproduced pop-rock with theatrical vibes and universal, if broad, lyrics.

With summer 2025 ahead, Benson Boone is gearing up for a season in the spotlight. Whether you love or cringe at his sound, one thing’s clear: he’s here to make noise.

Album Details

• Record label: Night Street / Warner
• Release date: June 20, 2025

Your Thoughts?

Do you think Benson Boone’s bold style will win over more fans, or is he destined to be a passing pop moment? Share your take!

FAQs

• What genre is Benson Boone’s ‘American Heart’?
  ‘American Heart’ is a pop-rock album with catchy hooks, theatrical elements, and emotional ballads.
• How long did it take to create the album?
  The album was written in just 17 days with collaborator Jack LaFrantz.
• What inspired the title ‘American Heart’?
  Despite patriotic imagery, Boone describes it as a love letter to his younger, idealistic self.
• What’s notable about Benson Boone’s public image?
  Boone is known for being wholesome, avoiding drugs and alcohol, and showing playful, bold stage antics.
• Are there standout tracks on the album?
  “Sorry I’m Here For Someone Else” and “I Wanna Be The One You Call” are among the more memorable tracks.

Ready to bring a piece of Benson Boone’s vibe home? Shop your favorite album cover poster at our store and add some pop-rock flair to your space!