Heavy Metal Nun Band Dogma Splits Amid Accusations of Manipulation and Mistreatment

Heavy metal nun band Dogma faces turmoil as former members speak out on manipulation and mistreatment, shaking the band's future.

When the Masks Come Off: Dogma’s Dramatic Implosion

If you’ve ever been captivated by Dogma’s electrifying blend of heavy metal and theatrical flair—dressed as nuns no less—you might be as stunned as I am by their recent implosion. The band, known for their unique aesthetic and commanding stage presence, has been rocked by serious accusations from former members about manipulation and mistreatment within the group and their management.

Just last month, three former members—singer Grace Jane Pasturini (aka Lilith), guitarist Amber Maldonado (Lamia), and guitarist Patri Grief (Rusalka)—issued a joint statement that sent shockwaves through the metal community. They revealed a darker side behind the band’s theatrical façade, accusing the management of unilateral decisions, broken promises, and outright lies fed to loyal fans.

“We were part of Dogma. We love this project, but what’s being sold today is not Dogma. During the tours, we saw unilateral decisions, broken promises, manipulation, mistreatment, and lies to the fans.”

The trio didn’t mince words, calling the individual now controlling the project “a threat” to the band’s future. This person, intriguingly, isn’t even a musician. “He turned the band into a brand, and people into disposable pieces. He betrayed the artists, his partners, and the fans,” they further explained. For fans like me, who have always felt connected to the soul behind the act, this was a jarring revelation.

A Call for Fans: Don’t Support a Lie

The former members urged fans to raise their voices: “Don’t support a lie. The social networks using the name Official Dogma no longer represent the real band or what we stand for.”

They implored for transparency and accountability, advising fans to demand refunds if they weren’t given what was promised and to stop being manipulated. The symbolism of the masks, once a shield of anonymity, has been twisted, they said: “Masks were meant to protect identity, not to replace people. The only one who needs to take off the mask is him.”

This passionate plea highlighted the resilience of the artists behind Dogma, promising that despite the turmoil, “The music, the creativity, and the truth are on our side.”

Dogma’s Response: Bigger Than Any One Individual

In the face of these accusations, Dogma responded with a statement emphasizing the band’s collective nature. They acknowledged the contributions of all past and present members but stressed that the band transcends any single individual.

“Dogma was founded on creativity, collaboration, and evolution. Like any artistic project, change is part of our growth. Every member, past and present, has left a mark that helped shape who we are today, but Dogma’s vision and music continue to move forward through the dedication of the current team and the support of our fans.”

They reiterated their commitment to core values: authenticity, freedom of expression, and connection through art. The statement concluded with a heartfelt message to fans: “Dogma was never about who we are, it’s about what YOU choose to become…”

More Voices Join the Chorus of Concern

The saga doesn’t stop there. Musician Kim Jennett recently shared her experience, revealing she was almost hired as Dogma’s new singer in 2024 but rejected the offer due to what she described as an “insulting” contract.

Jennett expressed solidarity with the women previously involved, highlighting the silencing effect of contracts and legal threats that prevent them from speaking openly.

“The contract I was sent was one of the most insulting things I’ve seen in my 15-year career. My lawyer said it was essentially ‘slave labour’ and told me not to go anywhere near it. I completely understand that not everyone has access to legal advice, and I don’t blame the women who signed. They were sold a dream, manipulated with false promises and hope, into signing something that ultimately exploited them.”

She further exposed the meager pay—just $100 per show—while managers reportedly pocketed profits from merchandise, ticket sales, and meet-and-greets. But it’s more than money; it’s about control, Jennett insisted: “Legally bound to hide behind characters and keep mouths shut. Replaceable and exploited, all disguised behind a mask of ‘feminism.’”

Amber Maldonado Speaks Out Again

Adding fuel to the fire, Amber Maldonado issued another statement revealing conflicts with the band’s management regarding her work schedule and compensation.

She recounted how she was questioned about compensating the management company for lost revenue when she missed a meet-and-greet, despite offering those for free. On her days off from touring, she was asked to attend interviews scripted with AI-generated “word salad” she was expected to follow, none of which were compensated.

Such revelations give a glimpse of the intense pressures and control mechanisms that seem to have suffocated the band behind the scenes.

Alice Chiara’s Departure: Visa Issues and Miscommunication

Former guitarist Alice Chiara (Lamia III) also opened up about her exit from Dogma, which came about a month and a half ago after European shows.

Her departure stemmed largely from visa complications for the U.S. tour. She was contacted just a month before the nearly two-month tour across the USA, Australia, and Asia but wasn’t granted a work visa to perform in the States.

Adding insult to injury, Alice found out about an April tour announced on social media without her being informed directly. When she voiced her concerns, management brushed them off with, “there is still time.”

What’s Next for Dogma?

With all these allegations and upheaval, Dogma’s future hangs in the balance. The band is scheduled for an Australian tour later this month, followed by UK and European dates in the spring. Whether the current lineup and management can weather this storm remains to be seen.

For fans who have been drawn to Dogma’s mix of fierce music and striking visual identity, this saga is a sobering reminder that behind the masks, real people and complicated dynamics exist.

FAQ

• What led to the rift within Dogma?
  Former members accused management of manipulation, mistreatment, broken promises, and turning the band into a mere brand rather than an authentic artistic project.
• Who are the former members speaking out?
  Singer Grace Jane Pasturini (Lilith), guitarist Amber Maldonado (Lamia), and guitarist Patri Grief (Rusalka) have publicly criticized the band’s management and leadership.
• What did Kim Jennett reveal about joining Dogma?
  Jennett nearly became the new singer but declined due to an exploitative contract offering low pay and harsh restrictions.
• How has Dogma management responded?
  They emphasized Dogma as a collaborative and evolving project and expressed gratitude to all past and present members, denying the accusations as defining their identity.
• What issues caused Alice Chiara to leave Dogma?
  Visa problems prevented her from performing in the U.S. tour, combined with poor communication and last-minute notifications about tours.

If you’re a fan of Dogma’s bold, theatrical heavy metal vibes, why not bring that energy into your space? Shop your favorite album cover poster at Architeg Prints and keep the spirit of heavy metal alive in your collection.