Sky Ferreira Claims Charli XCX’s ‘Wuthering Heights’ Draws From Her Old Songs: “I Have Proof of Everything”

Sky Ferreira hints that parts of Charli XCX’s ‘Wuthering Heights’ album borrow from her earlier work, backing her remarks with evidence.

When iconic pop voices collide, the sparks are bound to fly — and sometimes, so do the claims. Sky Ferreira recently stirred the pot by suggesting that Charli XCX’s latest soundtrack album, Wuthering Heights, includes elements taken from her own unreleased songs. As a longtime fan of both artists, I can’t help but dive into this juicy crossover drama, which blends artistic inspiration with a dash of behind-the-scenes intrigue.

A Soundtrack Steeped in Collaboration and Controversy

Earlier this year, Charli XCX released the official soundtrack for Emerald Fennell’s film Wuthering Heights. The album is a bewitching mix of gothic pop vibes and haunting melodies, featuring collaborations with legendary musicians like John Cale of The Velvet Underground, and, notably, Sky Ferreira herself.

Sky shares a vocal spotlight on the track “Eyes Of The World,” credited as a guest feature. But beyond that friendly collaboration, Ferreira has now dropped hints through Instagram messages that some parts of the album might actually be borrowing from her own older material.

This revelation is especially fascinating because Sky has been quietly crafting music for years, often battling industry setbacks that left some of her work unreleased. So, the idea that Charli’s project might be lifting from those hidden gems adds an intriguing layer to both artists’ creative stories.

The 'Old Song' Claims: What’s the Buzz?

Here’s where things get spicy. A social media user quoted an “industry insider” claiming that:

• The intro of Charli’s song “Chains Of Love” is allegedly lifted from Ferreira’s demo “Ancient Idols,” a track dating back to around 2018 intended for her still-unreleased second album Masochism.
• Another track, “Altars,” is said to be inspired by an even older Ferreira demo from 2015.

These are serious allegations in the music world, especially considering how fiercely artists guard their originality.

When Ferreira responded, she didn’t outright confirm the specifics but didn’t dismiss the idea either. She wrote: “Your industry ‘insider’ is wrong. Close but wrong.” Later, she added with a tone of quiet assertiveness, “I’m not going to get into it but it was definitely more than an intro. I have proof of everything with dates. It isn’t worth the trouble bc I know how the world works.”

That last line says a lot — a knowing nod to the often complicated and sometimes frustrating mechanics behind music credits and ownership.

Sky Ferreira and Charli XCX have collaborated before, but recent claims hint at deeper creative overlaps.

The History Between Sky Ferreira and Charli XCX

Their collaboration history actually dates back several years. In 2019, they teamed up for the single “Cross You Out,” a slick, synth-pop track that showcased both their bold styles. Charli once described working with Sky as “amazing,” praising her taste and vision.

Fast forward to the summer of 2024, Charli openly shared her admiration for both Rihanna and Ferreira, ranking Sky above all pop stars except Rihanna. She called Sky “one of a kind,” which revealed a deep respect beyond just musical compatibility.

Later in 2024, Charli celebrated Ferreira’s new song “Leash,” recorded for the A24 film Babygirl starring Nicole Kidman. She took to social media with a playful shoutout: “I was already so excited for Babygirl but now we get Babygirl + a new song from Sky: omg. stan mode activated.” It’s clear these two have personal and artistic admiration, adding complexity to Ferreira’s recent claims.

Sky Ferreira’s Fight for Control Over Her Music

This drama comes at a time when Sky Ferreira has been vocal about taking back ownership of her songs after being dropped by her label, Capitol Records. In late 2023, she was officially removed from Capitol’s roster — a tough break for any artist, especially one with unreleased treasures like Masochism tucked away.

Knowing this context, Ferreira’s recent comments about having “proof” and “dates” that back her claims feel like more than just casual chatter — they seem rooted in a battle for recognition and rights to her creative output.

Charli XCX and Sky Ferreira’s collaboration on “Eyes of the World” blends their unique styles in this official lyric video.

Charli XCX Has Yet to Address the Claims

As of now, Charli XCX has not publicly responded to Ferreira’s hints about song inspirations and possible borrowing. Whether this silence signals a behind-the-scenes resolution or simply a decision to avoid stirring the pot remains to be seen.

What Does This Mean for Fans?

For fans of both artists, this revelation is a bittersweet moment — it spotlights the sometimes tangled realities of the music business while reminding us how intertwined creative journeys can be. It’s tempting to see this as a musical mystery or even a soap opera, but at its heart, it’s a story about artistry, ownership, and respect.

“I have proof of everything with dates. It isn’t worth the trouble bc I know how the world works.”
— Sky Ferreira

FAQ

• What are the songs Sky Ferreira claims were influenced by her work?
  Ferreira suggests parts of “Chains Of Love” and “Altars” from Charli’s Wuthering Heights may have drawn from her demos “Ancient Idols” (2018) and another demo from 2015.
• Has Charli XCX responded to these claims?
  No official public response from Charli XCX has been made regarding Ferreira’s statements.
• How long have Sky Ferreira and Charli XCX worked together?
  Their collaboration dates back to at least 2019 with the single “Cross You Out,” and they’ve maintained a friendly artistic relationship since.
• Why is Sky Ferreira fighting for ownership of her music?
  After being dropped by Capitol Records in 2023, Ferreira has been trying to regain control of her unreleased and existing songs.
• Is “Eyes Of The World” the only confirmed collaboration between them on this album?
  Yes, Ferreira is officially credited as a guest on that track, but claims about further influences remain unconfirmed.

If you’re inspired by the visual and musical artistry of these pop icons, consider adding a touch of their vibe to your own space. Shop your favorite album cover posters and celebrate the soundtracks that shape your world at Architeg Prints.