Turnstiles Frontman Shares the Magic of Surprise Billy Joel Performance

Billy Joel’s unforgettable surprise with Turnstiles reignites the timeless appeal of his music and gives the tribute band a thrilling new chapter.

A Night to Remember: When Billy Joel Joined Turnstiles Onstage

Imagine this: an ailing rock legend, cane in hand, stepping onto a stage not as the headliner but to join a tribute band playing his own iconic songs. That’s exactly what unfolded on January 2, 2026, in Wellington, Florida, when Billy Joel made a heart-stirring surprise appearance with Turnstiles, a band devoted to honoring his music.

After a year away from the tour circuit, recovering from normal pressure hydrocephalus, the 76-year-old piano man showed the indomitable spirit of a true performer. With a cane steadying his steps, he joined Turnstiles to belt out “We Didn’t Start the Fire” and “Big Shot” during Wellington’s 30th anniversary concert. Footage of this rare gig quickly went viral, sending waves of excitement through the music world and fans alike.

The Frontman’s Take: Tony Monaco Reflects on an Unbelievable Moment

Tony Monaco, Turnstiles’ 70-year-old frontman and a retired auto collision expert, has been riding an adrenaline high ever since. Born in Pittsburgh and seasoned by life in Long Island before settling in Florida, Tony’s been carrying the torch for Billy Joel’s legacy through the band Turnstiles for decades.

“I had no idea Billy was gonna be there. After it all started happening, I still never got past, my God, we’re gonna play with Billy!” — Tony Monaco

Tony recalls the surreal experience vividly: “The band went to eat after the show, and we were just sitting there in la la land. Then I realized it was Billy’s first public appearance since announcing his condition. By the next day, I’d gotten 67 phone calls. We’re a little overwhelmed!” The excitement is infectious, and you can almost feel it through his words.

How Did This Surprise Come About? A Backstage Story

You might wonder how a tribute band and a music legend crossed paths in such a magical way. For years, Turnstiles had played at Wellington’s amphitheater, and while Billy Joel had ties to the area, he wasn’t a full-time local. The night of the 30th anniversary concert was special—Turnstiles headlined alongside two other bands.

Just an hour before showtime, Tony was told a visitor was waiting for him: Billy’s daughters and the man himself, accompanied by his wife, Alexis.

“Billy said he wanted to meet us, which was surreal. I asked if I could mention he was there, and Alexis hinted he might want to play. When he saw our setlist, he recognized it as his own,” Tony shared with a chuckle.

The first song they played was “New York State of Mind,” with Billy initially out in the crowd. But after the second song, “Scenes From an Italian Restaurant,” Billy quietly walked onstage. The crowd of around 6,000 erupted in cheers.

Billy chose “We Didn’t Start the Fire” as his grand entrance number, singing the entire first verse flawlessly despite his health struggles. Then, with a twinkle in his eye, he opted for “Big Shot,” playfully scolding the drummer for speeding up the tempo.

“It was fun. It was exhilarating. Something I’ll never forget as long as I live.” — Tony Monaco

The Journey So Far: From Madison Square Garden to Viral Stardom

Before this unforgettable night, Turnstiles had their own brush with greatness when Vampire Weekend invited them to open at New York’s Madison Square Garden in October 2024—a rare honor for a tribute band.

Tony reflects, “The Garden helped propel us to a different clientele, people willing to spend a bit more. Vampire Weekend’s manager congratulated us and wished us a Happy New Year. I hope we’ll be doing more shows with them.”

This boost in visibility helped Turnstiles grow beyond the typical tribute band circuit, and the recent Billy Joel collaboration pushed their profile even further.

Why Billy Joel’s Music Still Resonates Deeply

Billy Joel’s music isn’t just notes and lyrics; it’s a cultural touchstone, especially for those from the Northeast who grew up with his songs as the soundtrack of life’s milestones. Tony puts it beautifully:

“Billy’s music is a form of home. It was to their parents what Sinatra was to previous generations. His records are so diverse—‘Scandinavian Skies’ to ‘It’s Still Rock’n’Roll to Me’—it’s like the same artist with many faces.”

The appeal spans generations, with audiences ranging from toddlers to seniors, all singing along at festivals and shows. Billy’s straightforward storytelling and unmatched wordcraft give his music an evergreen charm. Few artists can sell out 150 shows at Madison Square Garden like he did.

A Glimpse of the Future: Billy’s Road to Recovery and Turnstiles’ Rise

Tony sensed Billy’s determination during their performance and believes the piano legend might make a comeback, even if on a smaller scale.

“He wasn’t 100%, but his voice was strong. I think he wants to play again and hasn’t shut the door on it. This might have been a little test of those waters.”

For Turnstiles, 2026 looks promising with new band members elevating their sound and an expanding schedule, including talks of a Fourth of July show overseas.

“We’re mostly in Florida, but summer will take us up and down the East Coast. I think it’s going to be a very special year,” Tony says.

Turning the Spotlight on Billy Joel’s Legacy and Turnstiles’ Journey

Billy Joel’s surprise performance with Turnstiles wasn’t just a fleeting moment—it was a reminder of music's power to connect, heal, and inspire. For Tony Monaco and his band, it’s a milestone that reaffirms their passion and dedication to keeping the Piano Man’s legacy alive.

FAQ

• How did Billy Joel’s surprise performance with Turnstiles come about?
  Billy Joel and his family showed up unannounced at Turnstiles’ Wellington concert and decided to join the band onstage for a few of his classic songs.
• What songs did Billy Joel perform with Turnstiles?
  He performed “New York State of Mind,” “We Didn’t Start the Fire,” and “Big Shot.”
• Has Turnstiles performed at any major venues before?
  Yes, they opened for Vampire Weekend at Madison Square Garden in 2024, making them the only tribute band to play there.
• Why does Billy Joel’s music still resonate with so many?
  His songs offer relatable stories and timeless melodies that span generations, especially resonant with people from the Northeast.
• What’s next for Turnstiles after this viral moment?
  The band plans to tour more broadly along the East Coast with new members enhancing their sound and is considering international gigs.

Celebrate your love for Billy Joel and Turnstiles by shopping for your favorite album cover poster at our store. These prints capture the spirit of the Piano Man’s timeless legacy and the tribute band’s rising journey. Shop now.